San Benito County Small Claims Court

Have a Small Claims Court Case in San Benito County or thinking of filing one? We have summarized the relevant information you need to know for when you go to the San Benito County Small Claims Court.  

San Benito County conducts small claims court hearings in Hollister. Here is the address:

San Benito County Superior Court
450 Fourth Street
Hollister, CA 95023

Need to contact the San Benito Small Claims Court Clerk? Here is how:  

By Phone

• Small Claims Clerk: (831) 636-4057

• Phone Hours: 8:00 AM until 4:00 PM

Website: http://www.sanbenito.courts.ca.gov/#Page_9

You can always sue an individual in San Benito County small claims court if they live in San Benito County. You can always sue a business in San Benito County small claims court if the business is located in San Benito County.

You may be able to sue in San Benito small claims in other situations. For example:

• If you are suing about a car accident that occurred in San Benito County.

• If you are suing about damage to your house that occurred in San Benito County.

• If you have an issue with your landlord returning the security deposit and the rented unit was in Hollister, Paicines, San Juan Bautista or anywhere in San Benito County then you would be able to sue your landlord in San Benito County Small Claims Court (you would also be able to sue your landlord in the small claims court in the county where they live).

If the defendant lives in the following cities/towns then you can sue in San Benito Small Claims Court: Hollister, Paicines, San Juan Bautista, and Tres Pinos.

So long as there isn't another court better suited to hear the case, then the lawsuit can be filed in small claims. The most common types of small claims cases in San Benito County Small Claims Court are:

• Landlord/Tenant disputes over the security deposit.

• Landlord/Tenant disputes over early termination of the lease.

• Unpaid rent.

• Roommate disputes.

• Disputes over loans.

• Contracts (written and oral).

• Auto accidents.

• Disputes over auto repairs.

• Disputes over remodeling or home repairs.

• Damage caused to property.

• Unpaid bills.

• Do not wait to file your small claims court lawsuit! After an incident occurs, you only have a set period of time to file your lawsuit. Think of this as a deadline (called the statute of limitations). Once the deadline is reached, you cannot file your California Small Claims Court lawsuit.  

• Read Common statutes of limitations for San Benito Small Claims Court.  

This is also known as the "small claims court limits." In San Benito Small Claims:

• An individual or sole proprietor can sue for $12,500 or less.

• A corporation or LLC can sue for $6,250 or less.

The amount you will pay to file a small claims lawsuit in San Benito County depends on how much you are suing for:

• If you are suing for $1,500 or less, then your filing fee is $30.

• If you are suing for more than $1,500 but less than or equal to $5,000, then your filing fee is $50.

• If you are suing for more than $5,000, then your filing fee is $75.

In most small claims cases, you can expect to pay:

• Filing fees (see above) $30- $75

• Serving Costs can range from $15-$100

If you win your case, you can request that the losing party pay for "reasonable costs." Use our interactive cost calculator to learn more.

When will the Small Claims Hearing be?

• Once a case is filed in San Benito County Small Claims Court, the hearing will be scheduled within 30- 70 days.

• You must serve the small claims lawsuit on the defendant at least 15 days before the hearing if the defendant lives or resides within San Benito County. If the defendant resides outside of San Benito County, you must serve them at least 20 days before the hearing. If you use "substituted service" these deadlines differ (25 days before the hearing if the defendant lives or resides within San Benito County and 30 days before the hearing if the defendant resides outside the county).

• Make sure to file "Proof of Service" at least 5 days before the hearing.  

How to prepare for a Small Claims Court Hearing?

You have filed your case and served the defendant. The next step is to start preparing for your Small Claims Court hearing.

• Research the law. If you are unsure about your case, consult an attorney, or conduct your own research about the law.

• Prepare your evidence. Invoices, contracts, receipts, etc. You want to have your evidence organized with titles, dates, and why that piece of evidence is important. All your evidence should be geared towards showing the judge why you are correct.

• Prepare what to say. During the hearing, the judge will ask the person suing why they are suing.  If you are being sued, you will be asked why you don't owe the other party money.

• Get your receipts for costs ready. For example, your filing fees and any process server costs. Make sure to let the judge know that you would like to be reimbursed for costs.  

• Print enough copies of all your evidence. You will need at least three copies (one for you, one for the judge, one for the other side).

What happens on the hearing date?

Give yourself plenty of time.

You do not want to be late for your hearing. Give yourself plenty of time for parking and navigating the courthouse.

Once You Walk into the Courthouse...

• Once you walk in, the first thing you will see is airport-like security. You will need to put your belongings through the metal detector. You can bring in laptops and cellphones, unlike some courthouses.

Once you arrive at the courtroom, locate your case on the paper schedule outside the courtroom door.

• Outside of each courtroom, there will be a printed list of the cases that have hearings on that day.

• You want to locate your case on the schedule. If you don't see your case listed, but you have received notice that your case will be heard that day, you may want to try and speak to the sheriff or clerk in the courtroom.

• Make sure to use that waiting time to organize your evidence or go to the restroom.

• Once the courtroom is opened, the court clerk, sheriff, and judge will go through what to expect. You will be sitting in a room with other people who have filed small claims cases. You will get to watch the cases before yours.  Make sure you are in the courtroom when your case is called!

The Hearing

If both parties show up:

• Right before the hearing, the judge will ask the parties to show each other the evidence that they have brought with them.  

• The Judge will ask the person who is suing why they are suing.

• Then the person who is being sued will get to present their side of the story.

• The hearing will last around 15 minutes.

• The judge will ask the parties to show the judge the evidence they brought with them. Sometimes the judge will keep the evidence other times you will get the evidence right back.

• Very rarely will a judge tell the parties their decision immediately after the hearing. Instead, the judge will tell the parties that the decision will be mailed to them (usually takes a few weeks to two months or so).

If only the plaintiff shows up:

• The plaintiff (the person who is suing) has to still prove their case. The plaintiff will have to tell the judge why they are suing and provide enough evidence.

If only the defendant shows up:

• The case gets dismissed without prejudice (meaning that the plaintiff can still file the case again later on.)

Are attorneys allowed in small claims court?

• Attorneys are not allowed to represent parties at the initial hearing. If the defendant appeals the case, then attorneys are allowed to represent the parties at the appeal hearing.

• You will not be able to hire a lawyer to represent you at the initial small claims court hearing.